Search
Warm autumn light crosses an elegant West Village townhouse parlor with a marble fireplace, linen seating, and tall windows overlooking a small brick-walled garden.

What a West Village Townhouse Costs Per Foot This Year

Two Village townhouse sales were filed in city records within five months of each other this year, a short walk apart. In February, 23 West 12th Street sold for $11.2 million. It is a 7,000-square-foot building set up as a triplex, a duplex and an owner's studio, and The Real Deal put the price at about $1,600 a square foot. At the end of June, 243-245 West 4th Street was recorded at $46 million. It is a combined double-wide compound of about 8,900 square feet, which works out to roughly $5,100 a foot.

Both are Village townhouses on paper, yet one sold for more than three times the other per foot. If you are pricing a house here, the useful number is the price per foot for your kind of house. The neighborhood average blends those kinds together.

The Average Went Up Because Bigger Houses Sold

The quarterly townhouse report most of the market follows combines the West and Greenwich Villages. For the first nine months of 2026, it shows 40 closings, 11 of them in the third quarter. Over the same period, the average sale price was $13.2 million, up 17.1% from a year earlier, while the average price per square foot fell 6.0% to $2,339. Year-to-date closings fell 7.0% and dollar volume rose 9.0% to $526.2 million.

If the average price rises while the price per foot falls, the houses that sold this year were mostly larger. They were not costing more per foot. The report says the same thing in its own terms. It attributes the drop in the average from $15 million at the end of the second quarter to an "extraordinary concentration of high-value transactions earlier in the year," and names 105-107 Bank Street and 243-245 West 4th Street.

The same pattern shows up borough-wide. The Real Deal reported in August that appraiser Jonathan Miller's second-quarter figures had the average Manhattan one- to three-family house above 5,000 square feet, up nearly 15% from a year earlier. Miller pointed to the size of the houses changing hands as one reason prices were climbing. So a buyer pricing a 4,000-square-foot house against the $13.2 million average is comparing it with a different, much larger set of houses. The rest of this post sorts the year's Village trades by what each house was, starting with the most expensive per foot.

Combined Double-Wides Traded at About $5,000 a Foot

The two largest trades of the year were both houses built by combining neighboring lots. 105-107 Bank Street is 40 feet wide. It came to market in October 2025 at $75 million and sold in May for $70 million. The Real Deal gave its size as about 14,000 square feet, which puts the sale near $5,000 a foot. That was a few million short of the downtown record, the $72.5 million Greenwich Village sale in 2024. The 243-245 West 4th Street sale came in at about $5,100 a foot.

These houses cost so much per foot because there are so few of them. A broker told the New York Post that putting together neighboring properties into a house that size is difficult and slow. The Post tied downtown demand to limited supply, tight zoning and historic protections. When only a handful of double-wides exist and one comes up for sale, there is little to compare it with, and buyers paid about $5,000 a foot this year.

A Bleecker Street Building With a Storefront

At 87 Perry Street, which also carries the address 385 Bleecker Street, the ground floor is a retail unit once occupied by a shoe brand that closed in 2024. Amber Valletta sold the three-story building off-market for just under $10 million to an entity linked to Acadia Realty Trust. According to The Real Deal, Acadia's portfolio already includes 387 Bleecker next door and 382-384 Bleecker nearby. City records show the price as $9,999,990. The building has about 2,576 square feet and is classified as a two-family dwelling with a store. That works out to roughly $3,900 a foot, which is more per foot than any of the finished single-family houses below.

The upstairs apartment had been rented out. It asked $16,000 a month in 2024 and was relisted at $21,000 a month in June, then taken off the rental market in August once the sale contract was signed. This building has a storefront on Bleecker Street and sits beside buildings in the same buyer's portfolio, so its price per foot tells you little about what a family house on Perry Street would sell for.

Finished Single-Family Houses Ran $2,800 to $3,650

Most buyers reading this are shopping in this group: houses that are already renovated and set up for one household.

78 Morton Street is five stories and 25 feet wide, with an elevator, a media room, outdoor space, a garage and a lower level fitted out as a jazz club. It sold for $19 million, about $2,800 a foot on nearly 6,900 square feet. That was $2 million under its original asking price, and the listing had gone live the previous April. The seller had paid $19.2 million in 2020.

In Greenwich Village, 150 West 11th Street was recorded in June at just under $11 million. On about 3,300 square feet, that comes to roughly $3,300 a foot. The house is a three-bedroom Greek Revival that had already had an extensive renovation when it was listed in 2018.

48 Jane Street is the most recent house in this group, and the one data point here that is a contract rather than a closing. It is four stories and 22.5 feet wide, with 4,100 square feet, five bedrooms, a back garden, skylights, wood-burning fireplaces and a cellar. The sellers renovated it with the architects Fairfax & Sammons. The house had not changed hands since 1996. It came to market asking $15.5 million and was asking just under $15 million when it went to contract in the last week of September. It was the most expensive Manhattan home to sign a contract that week. That last ask is about $3,650 a foot.

In this group, the smaller house was the more expensive per foot. Morton Street is the biggest of the three and the cheapest per foot, and Jane Street is the smallest and the priciest. A 25-foot house with an elevator and a garage sold for less per foot than a 4,100-square-foot house with a garden, so buyers are not paying the same per-foot rate for every extra foot. Most of the headline sales listed above cleared well above the $2,339 Village average. That suggests the average is being pulled down by sales that never made the news.

Houses Still Divided Into Units Sold Near $1,600

At the low end per foot are houses that are not yet set up as single-family homes. 23 West 12th Street is the clearest example. Its listing said the triplex, duplex and studio could be converted into one mansion. It hit the market asking just under $15 million and sold for $11.2 million. That is about 25% below the ask, the largest discount of any sale in this post, and the buyer still has the conversion to pay for.

A house like this has little in common with a finished house on Jane Street, but both kinds count as Village townhouses in the neighborhood averages.

Discounts From Asking Followed the Same Pattern

The size of each discount lined up with the kind of house. Through September, the Village report put the gap between final asking price and sale price at 5.0%. Measured from each house's first asking price, the gaps were wider. Bank Street closed about 7% under its launch price, Morton Street about 10% under, and 23 West 12th Street about 25% under. Jane Street had dropped about $500,000 from its first ask before it went to contract. In this year's sales, the house still divided into units gave up the most from their first asking prices.

Supply is the reason sellers could hold their prices at all. Per The Real Deal's August account, Manhattan townhouse listings rose from a year earlier in the second quarter but remained more than 20% below the ten-year average. The Village report described buyers as "highly selective," with deep demand for houses that combine location, architectural character, size and quality. Buyers showed that selectivity in how much less they paid for houses lacking those qualities.

A Few Questions Buyers Ask

Is $2,339 a foot a fair benchmark for a renovated Village single-family house? Only as a floor. The finished single-family houses that sold or went to contract this year ran from about $2,800 a foot on closed price to about $3,650 on last asking price. The $2,339 figure averages them with multi-unit buildings and conversion projects.

Do wider houses always cost more per foot? Not in this year's sales. Morton Street is 25 feet wide and sold for less per foot than the narrower Jane Street house was asking. Combined double-wides like Bank Street and West 4th Street are a separate group, priced by how rare they are.

What does a multi-unit house trade for compared with a finished one? 23 West 12th Street sold near $1,600 a foot and closed about 25% under its ask, so the buyer bought below the renovated houses and took on the conversion work.

Before you price a Village townhouse, work out which of these groups it belongs to. Our buyers team works from house-by-house comparisons like the ones above. If you own a townhouse on these blocks, DTNYC Team can compare it with the sales in its own group. Request a VIP Market Valuation through our home valuation page.

Follow Us On Instagram